Financial Commission rulings take Q3 awards to $112,794

A computer trading screen at a workstation, illustrating account-access complaints against brokers.
Photo by AlphaTradeZone on Pexels

Awards and complaint mix

The Financial Commission recorded $112,794 in awards for the third quarter of 2026 by 11 November 2026. Decisions issued after the quarter ended lifted the total from its initial $75,585. Complaints were up 9% on the first quarter.

The initial awards represented about 1.2% of the $6.22 million clients sought from member brokers, against 3.1% across 2025. The Commission is a private dispute forum, not a regulator.

Its Dispute Resolution Committee's decisions bind a member broker only if the trader accepts the outcome. In 2025, it found brokers at fault in 76 of 1,468 complaints, or 5.2%.

Account access complaints increase

Complaints classified as unauthorized account access climbed from 43 in the second quarter to 84 in the third, with $507,602 at issue. Nikolai Isayev, the Commission's chief operating officer, said in written answers on 11 November that 11 cases had been decided on their merits, all in the broker's favour. Another 37 closed without a merits decision and 36 remained open. He said the committee considers each case separately.

Public enforcement records show few phishing references: the Fines & Warnings Tracker contained 6,680 regulatory updates through 6 November 2026, with seven mentioning phishing. A client told XTB that a third party had depleted about 150,000 zloty (about $38,000) through trading. XTB responded by requiring two-factor authentication from July 2025. Hackers may have obtained client MetaTrader logins at a server host, after which OANDA Japan paused withdrawals in October.

MeasureFigure
Initial third-quarter awards$75,585
Awards by 11 November 2026$112,794
Client claims against member brokers$6.22 million
Account-access complaints, Q2 to Q343 to 84
Amount disputed in account-access cases$507,602
Account-access cases decided on the merits11, all for the broker
Closed without a merits ruling37
Account-access cases pending36
Complaints awaiting a decision at report time, then by 11 November158, then 144
Trading complaints, Q2 to Q3283 to 455

What an operations team should check

The Commission later put the overall pending caseload at 144, down from 158 when the report was prepared. It said 43 third-quarter decisions favoured traders.

The awards remained about 74% below the first quarter's published amount. Financial complaints held at about 270, while trading complaints increased to 455 from 283.

The Commission publishes quarterly complaint totals without results split by broker; it has 49 broker members. The figures, first reported by Finance Magnates, do not show broker-level outcomes. For risk and operations teams, the useful questions are whether account-access disputes can be reconstructed from authentication, session and withdrawal records, and what evidence is available to assess alleged third-party activity.

Operations teams can check whether their incident records connect login activity with trades and withdrawal requests, and whether those records can support a complaint review. They should also establish what the available data can show about third-party access, since the Commission's published account-access decisions have so far favoured brokers. The reported totals do not specify which controls or evidence drove those decisions.