Futures prop firms are bringing in less from challenge sales while per-user platform and data charges continue to weigh on their costs. Manuel Sonnleithner, co-founder and CEO of TradersYard, said internal industry data put net margins at 10-15%, down from about 25-30%.
Firms face pressure on revenue, account expenses and payouts at the same time. The squeeze has already led some operators to change payout terms, transfer profitable traders to live accounts sooner or shut down. It also puts platform access and recurring technology bills at the centre of decisions about whether a futures prop model can scale.
Price cuts meet recurring platform costs
Entry prices have fallen. Sonnleithner said a Topstep 50K account previously cost $49 a month, with a $149 activation fee. A trader passing in the first month therefore brought in about $200, excluding resets.
Models without activation charges and subscriptions spread during 2025, with Lucid among the firms that helped popularise them. Promotions took the effective price of some 50K accounts to $90-$100, reducing income when a trader reached funded status.
Gil Ben Hur, founder of The5ers, linked discounting to competition from new firms using what he called a "me-too product strategy". He said firms were removing trading rules and offering steep discounts, fuelling a "race to the bottom". Finance Magnates had previously reported that, after the 2024 shakeout, challenge pass rates fell and average trader investments across prop trading dropped about 50%.
Technology expenses do not necessarily fall alongside challenge prices. Providers charge by user and month, Sonnleithner said, making a $49 challenge difficult to offer profitably when a provider costs $30/user/month.
Ruben Abitbol of RUBIK said a futures prop firm generally spends more to operate than a CFD firm, pointing to platform expenses around Tradovate and NinjaTrader as well as CME market-data fees. Anish Lal of Blackbull Markets added that professional-tier data classification can take monthly data costs to $2,000.
The billing cadence can compound the mismatch: CME charges monthly for each active user, while firms increasingly sell challenges as a one-off purchase. Payouts are another pressure point. Abitbol's broad comparison put CFD prop payout ratios at 40-50% and futures at 70-80%.
He said futures firms rely on "significantly higher volume" to bridge the difference. He also described futures traders as more sophisticated, with profitable traders potentially representing a larger liability while still trading in simulation.
Closures expose platform dependencies
Firms have responded by lowering payout ceilings, tightening payout arrangements and moving consistently profitable traders to live accounts earlier, Sonnleithner said. Abitbol said this move is more established in futures prop than in CFD prop.
Tradeify's Vinan Mistry identified fraud, including increasingly difficult-to-detect hedging groups, as the firm's biggest internal risk. Shervin Arian said firms that manage liabilities well price payout risk accurately instead of relying on fee reductions.
FundingTicks, the futures arm of FundingPips, launched in July 2025 and started winding down in January 2026. The firm had changed its terms in December, introducing a one-minute minimum hold, raising daily profit requirements and reducing profit splits.
Sonnleithner saw the closure as following fee reductions intended to win market share and significant losses, while cautioning that pricing might not have been the only cause. The sequence was reported by Finance Magnates.
Other exits have highlighted reliance on platform providers. Alpha Futures ended its Premium Plan in July after NinjaTrader terminated its partnership.
It refunded accounts but did not honour unpaid payouts beyond those already made, while keeping its other plans open. Angelo Ciaramello, founder of The Funded Trader, closed Rev One in August, saying the firm lacked a leading platform option and could not scale as a result. FundedSeat shut in late September, after two years and monthly payouts of nearly $700,000. It did not support NinjaTrader or Tradovate, and its letter to traders pointed to limitations imposed by major trading platforms.
ProjectX planned to end third-party service at the end of February 2026, leaving Topstep as its sole platform user. Tradeify, Bulenox, Alpha Futures, Lucid and Top One Futures instead migrated their platforms and remained open. Abitbol said some larger firms are developing platforms of their own to gain more control over costs, data and risk management. He expects investment in behavioural analysis and trader verification to narrow the risk-management gap. Ben Hur described operating a futures prop firm in the current competitive environment as "a very risky business".
What this means on the desk
For technology and operations teams, the commercial pressure lands in the recurring cost of each active account, data classification and the work required to maintain a viable platform path. A challenge sold once may still trigger monthly charges. Teams should check how those charges behave when user numbers rise, and how data costs change if a trader falls into a professional tier.
Risk teams also need to understand how payout caps, live-account transfers and fraud controls fit together. The firms in the report took different routes, from changing payout terms to migrating platforms or building their own. Operators assessing their own exposure should ask what happens to trader access, account records and pending payouts if a provider relationship ends, and what evidence supports their payout-liability assumptions.
Platforms · Software · Providers · Markets