Payout accounting lifts reported turnover
Prediction Frontier's Q3 report put nominal prediction-market turnover at $179.6 billion, while traders' purchase payments came to $56.1 billion. It attributes the $123 billion difference to the way venues record low-priced multi-outcome combos. Its coverage spans Kalshi, Polymarket's international and US venues, and Novig.
The report assigns each contract a $1 value based on its possible payout; its alternative measure, dollars paid, uses the execution price. In its example, buying 100 contracts at three cents each creates $100 of nominal turnover against $3 paid. Kalshi combos pay $1 only when every outcome in the package settles at $1. A zero result on any component makes the complete contract worth nothing. The structure means a small purchase can register as much larger nominal activity. Neither measure tracks new deposits, since contracts may change hands more than once and balances can be used again.
Kalshi activity drove the divergence
Kalshi's combo contracts contributed $67.1 billion, over one-third of the four-venue nominal total. Average payment for each $1 contract on the venue declined from 32 cents in July to 24 cents in September. Polymarket stayed close to 50 cents.
That pricing shift complicates comparisons of monthly peaks. Kalshi recorded $60.7 billion of nominal volume in September, against $14.7 billion paid, which the report says was only 10% above July. Across the venues, nominal activity increased 84.3% quarter on quarter, while purchase payments rose 54.7%. The multiple moved from about 2.7 in Q2 to 3.2 in Q3.
Coverage was not constant: Novig figures enter the comparison from August 4. Both measures advanced in Q3, but the widening spread means volume rankings can reflect contract pricing as well as activity. The findings are from Prediction Frontier's analysis, also reported by Finance Magnates.
What this changes for operators
Operators should check whether venue feeds and internal dashboards distinguish payout-based volume from execution-price payments, and whether monthly comparisons account for changes in contract pricing. The report does not establish how firms' risk or customer-activity systems use these measures, so that mapping needs to be verified locally.
The coverage change also affects comparisons: Novig enters the dataset only on August 4. Teams using quarter-on-quarter growth should verify that their comparison set is consistent, then decide which measure feeds customer-activity and venue-performance reporting.
Platforms · Software · Providers · Markets